New Idea.

[quackadilly]

With the addition of 6 and 7 star rating, JCirri introduced a star numbering system too.

I was thinking it wouldnt be too hard to add an "average" star rating. And I say "average" very loosly. It could be a straight average, weighted by total points %, by total notes %, by either of the two also scaled with the "total possible" star rating for each song.

I would suggest just a straight average rating.

Example:

[quackadilly]

With the addition of 6 and 7 star rating, JCirri introduced a star numbering system too.

I was thinking it wouldnt be too hard to add an "average" star rating. And I say "average" very loosly. It could be a straight average, weighted by total points %, by total notes %, by either of the two also scaled with the "total possible" star rating for each song.

I would suggest just a straight average rating.

Example:

[Anders]

It makes little sense for krimsunmunkeys to have a higher star rating than ES942. The most consistent definition of total rating would be a simple extension of the definition of per-song ratings: (total score)/(total base score) + 2. (This is equivalent to weighted averaging by base score.)

[Anders]

It makes little sense for krimsunmunkeys to have a higher star rating than ES942. The most consistent definition of total rating would be a simple extension of the definition of per-song ratings: (total score)/(total base score) + 2. (This is equivalent to weighted averaging by base score.)

[quackadilly]

What I used for those numbers was the average star rating for individual songs.

Not weighted or anything special.


The main reason for the flip flop is this:

[quackadilly]

What I used for those numbers was the average star rating for individual songs.

Not weighted or anything special.


The main reason for the flip flop is this:

[Kronkk37]

[Kronkk37]

[Anders]

[Anders]

[quackadilly]

All I did was take the individual star ratings for each song, add them up and divide by 47.

There really is no need to do anything with total points since the star rating is essential a ratio.

[quackadilly]

All I did was take the individual star ratings for each song, add them up and divide by 47.

There really is no need to do anything with total points since the star rating is essential a ratio.

[ScaryAdam]

since we have decimals... shouldn't we use those as well for the star system? so if i have a 5.5 it is worth more than if i were to just have a 5? at least for the star average, i think that would be important.. and that way we could actually see where we stand with all the rest of the people very near us
_________________

GH2 GOALS:
Easy: Post my scores, finish gold starring
Medium: Post my scores, finish gold starring
Hard: Actually going through and doing it, 5-star on everything
Expert: Actually post all my new scores, 5-star remaining songs (10 left), Pass Jordan (grrrr)

[ScaryAdam]

since we have decimals... shouldn't we use those as well for the star system? so if i have a 5.5 it is worth more than if i were to just have a 5? at least for the star average, i think that would be important.. and that way we could actually see where we stand with all the rest of the people very near us
_________________

GH2 GOALS:
Easy: Post my scores, finish gold starring
Medium: Post my scores, finish gold starring
Hard: Actually going through and doing it, 5-star on everything
Expert: Actually post all my new scores, 5-star remaining songs (10 left), Pass Jordan (grrrr)

[quackadilly]

Those scores included the decimal part of the star ratings.

[quackadilly]

Those scores included the decimal part of the star ratings.